CCS Events
CCS Libraries
About CCS
CCS Projects
CCS Highlights

Publication Details

Ayodele, Ayo  (2006) Nigeria’s “Debt Cancellation” – a Big Scam! . In Defence of Marxism : -.

By Ayo Ayodele 25 May 2006

Recently the Obasanjo regime in Nigeria achieved something that only a few years ago would have seemed unthinkable: it paid off the foreign debt it had to the Paris Club. Thus $12billion dollars were paid in one instalment.

This was presented as a major victory for Obasanjo. Here we publish a brief comment that appeared in the recent edition of the Nigerian Marxist journal, the Workers’ Alternative. As the article points out, Nigeria has paid many billions of dollars in servicing its foreign, and in reality has paid back far more than it had ever borrowed.

The $12billion could have been used to improve the lives of ordinary Nigerians, instead it has gone to line the pockets of the imperialist bankers. This money was taken away from hungry Nigerian children, from pensioners who have not seen their pensions paid for months, from students who have seen their fees increased several times over. It is a direct transfer of wealth from the rich to the poor.

What is even more shocking is the fact that the money Nigeria has just coughed up is spent by US imperialism in just two months to finance its dirty war of plunder in Iraq.

Obasanjo’s attempt to change the Nigerian Constitution in order to guarantee himself a Third Term in office was rejected by the National Assembly. Some commentators have suggested that the payment of the $12billion was a way of Obasanjo strengthening his bid for a Third Term. A recent development may indicate that this was the case. Having just paid off the $12billion, the Nigerian Federal Government has just negotiated a new loan from China of $2.5billion. It also has plans for further bilateral loans of $3billion in 2006, $1.5billion in 2007 and $2billion in 2008. This is a total of $9billion dollars, on which new service charges will be imposed, thus laying a new debt burden on the Nigerian masses.

The Nigerian ruling elite is the loyal servant of imperialism. It has no interest in genuinely improving the lot of the Nigerian masses. All it is interested in is lining its own pockets.

It is not surprising why there were no mass jubilations on the streets when the news of the total cancellation of Nigerian’s debt to the Paris club filtered out. While the ruling elites, petty bourgeois intellectuals, cronies of the regime, etc, were busy singing praises, the mass majority of the people don’t really understand why all the noise.

As the news filtered out, the news of the non-payment of pensioners and the agonies they were facing shared the front pages, along with other stories of woe from the Niger-Delta, students’ fighting imposition of school fees in LASU, etc.

What is very clear is that nobody really believes that now that debts to the Paris club are ‘gone’ that the government would now spend money on improving the lives of the people. What ‘Baba’ [Obasanjo] thought would add more force to his third term agenda has not provoked celebrations of the street of Nigeria.

False and Cheap Propaganda
“Twelve billion dollars in Nigeria would have gone a long way towards saving children, immunization, healthcare, all kinds of things. But the donors (Paris Club) got greedy. They said, ‘Take the oil revenue … and instead of investing it in your needs, give it to us’.” These were the words of Professor Jeffrey Sachs a bourgeois economist.

It is very clear that the payment of over $12 billion to the Paris club within a period of six months is a major plunder. It is a major looting of the treasury. Presenting this as a gain tells us a lot about the morals of the ruling elites; they pass off poison as a lovely drink. $12 billion could definitely change the face of Nigeria, if spent wisely instead of blowing it on dubious debts.

Big time scam and plunder
The so-called foreign debts were totally fictitious and fraudulent. Obasanjo himself had acknowledged this several times over the years. Why would paying off a dubious debt be a democratic dividend? Secondly, the so-called debt had been paid up multiple fold.

The current pay off again confirms the real nature of things: that the imperialists are in firm control of the economy through their local collaborators in Government. This regime is a regime of the IMF. Everything it does is towards meeting up with the obligations of the IMF, towards satisfying the debt obligations.

For the past seven years, the Nigerian government has paid about $25 billion to foreign banks simply toward servicing the debt!

Meanwhile it finds it very difficult to pay pensioners their legitimate pensions and gratuity.All the various draconian policies were geared towards making it possible for the wealth of the country to be plundered.

Now that the debt is ‘gone’
The attitude of the mass majority towards the so-called debt cancellation is quite critical. It is a form of wait and see attitude. However, instinctively they do not believe a word coming from the mouths of the ruling elites.

Now that the treasury has been plundered to satisfy greedy and dubious foreign bankers are the wages of workers going to be increased, will promotions now be regular, will education and health now be available and free, will pensioners now smile, will the roads get repaired and better ones contracted, will unemployment disappear? The list is endless. Will things change for the better in Nigeria and will there not be new debts?

What is very clear is that those who will continue to smile are the same people who were responsible for the debt and looting of the various treasuries. The current debt rip off is very profitable to the foreign banks and their local collaborators. The ‘consultant’ also got fat pay cheques. It is only a matter of time before the massive corruption that surrounds this inhuman deal gets exposed. The only people who lost in this deal are the Nigerian masses.

Nigeria: Flashlight on Present Economic Reforms

By Ola Kazeem in Lagos 26 May 2006

It is highly imperative to respond point by point to various lies and misinformation being circulated by the present ruling class on the so-called “economic reforms”. As the regime is busy squeezing water and blood from the Nigerian working class, its economic think tanks are equally busy spreading lies and baseless propaganda about their non-existing achievements. The motto of the present regime is best described as “be economical”, not only economical with spending on welfare of the people; this regime is more aggressively economical with the truth.

The Federal Office of Statistics has to be closed down for not being too economical with the truth and only two individuals: the Finance Minister (Okonjo Iweala) and the Governor of the Central Bank of Nigeria are the only official truth tellers. They tell us how our economy is performing, how the masses are enjoying things and all the statistical figures are generated by them to backup their claim; no wonder we have been having wonderful economic data.

The guiding principle of the present economic reforms can be summed up as unprecedented cuts in public spending to make money available for debt management and settle some key individuals, excessive concentration of wealth in the hands of the extreme few. And most importantly, the acceptance of the fact that capitalism works only for the few at the expense of the overwhelming majority.

Pension Reforms’
Pension “reform” is ironically the most ‘laudable’, but actually laughable aspect of the present ‘reforms’. Some petty bourgeois and bourgeois economists are in the forefront of singing praise on this particular reform. It is sometimes called contributory pension scheme, because the employees and employers are jointly contributing funds for the pension of the employee.

This reform reflects the acceptance by the ruling class that this system is absolutely incapable of guaranteeing a decent living for Nigerian workers, even after retirement. It is nothing more than a drastic cut in the wages of the working class and accumulation of wealth in a few hands. All the contributions go to Pension Fund Administrators (PFA), who are responsible for the management of this fund. What a colossal wealth! No wonder we have seen the proliferation of existing banks applying for PFA licenses. The capitalists want to make money without even producing a pin.

More laughable are the reasons put across for introducing this reform.

  • Because of the failure of the past pension scheme;

  • To make funds available for long term investment thereby jumpstarting the economy;

  • To cultivate the culture of saving into the psyche of the Nigerian workers.

  • The unfettered access of employers to the pension account had been blamed for the failure of the previous scheme. They claimed that whenever employers ran into financial needs, it was too cheap for them to enter into pension account and thereby defaulted on the payments when due. To avoid this, a barrier needs to be placed between employers and the pension account. But actually, who is fooling who? What separates employers from the Pension Fund Administrators? Are the employers not the same as PFAs? What barrier presently exists between employers and the funds?

    What makes this present scheme much more criminal is that existing funds contain part of poor workers’ salaries. Employers will continue to run into financial needs for as long as capitalism exists, and as long as they run into financial needs, they will continue to plunder the pension funds. Government is already expressing fear over the safety of people’s funds, considering the rate at which Pension Administrators now buy cars and build new houses!

    The second reason is equally ridiculous. Is it true that there is no fund for long-term investment or the owners of these funds do not have faith in the economy and therefore prefer stashing it away in foreign banks? Is the availability of huge funds enough to encourage direct investment? The most outstanding characteristic of bourgeois economists is the narrow-mindedness in their analysis. They cannot connect the level of insecurity in the land with the investment level. The abysmally low aggregate demands, because of overwhelming poverty in the land, is none of their concern; 73% of Nigerians are living below $1 per day and if the poverty line is placed at $2, then 92% of Nigerians are poor.

    Lack of infrastructure has completely worsened the cost of doing business in Nigeria. As the recent World Bank report on doing business in 2005 indicated, Nigeria has one of the least efficient systems in the world. It is estimated that it costs 9.1% of GNIpc to do business in South Africa; it costs 95.2% of GNIpc to do the same in Nigeria. Bourgeois economists and their hangers-on do not bother themselves with these facts, because they are helpless in the face of the truth.

    Instability on all fronts does not encourage any real investment in any sector of the economy, and instability is part of life in backward countries. So rather than this scheme encouraging long term investment, it is expected to merely encourage making money out of money (M-M1), making cheap money available for the greedy, over bloated bourgeoisie, for luxury goods and unregulated siphoning off of wealth.

    The third reason is obviously a serious embarrassment and an insult to the already humiliated Nigerian working class. With the minimum wage in Nigeria standing at 5,200 Nairas per month ($1.20 per day) and with millions of Nigerians unemployed, how else are Nigerians expected to live? How can a family of four/five possibly live on that humiliating minimum wage and still be expected to make monthly savings? They are trying to blame the vulnerable and overexploited masses for their own inabilities. Accepting this fact is equivalent to agreeing with the failure of capitalism. The capitalist system is obviously already in its senile stage; it can no longer guarantee one iota of human progress.

    On the Bank Merger
    As part of these aggressive economic reforms, 92 banks were forcefully merged and eventually reduced to just over 20 banks. In the word of Soludo (CBN Governor), while presenting his new found formula to the Bankers’ Committee:

    “Mergers and acquisitions especially in the banking industry is now a global phenomenon. In the United States of America, there had been over 7,000 cases of bank mergers since 1980, while the same trend occurred in the United Kingdom and other European countries. Specifically, in the period 1997-1998, 203 bank mergers and acquisitions took place in the Euro area. Cross-country mergers are also taking hold. In 1998, a merger in France resulted in a new bank with a capital base of US$688 billion, while the merger of two banks in Germany in the same year created the second largest bank in Germany with a capital base of US$541 billion. In many emerging markets, including Argentina, Brazil and Korea, consolidation has also become prominent, as banks strive to become more competitive and resilient to shocks as well as reposition their operations to cope with the challenges of the increasingly globalized banking systems. In Korea, for example, the system was left with only 8 commercial banks with about 4,500 branches after consolidation.”

    However, Prof. Soludo did not say how many of these mergers were carried out in the Nigerian style. Professor Soludo was presenting this like a schoolteacher, teaching his students in a classroom. He was saying this in 2005 when Marx had already predicted this over 150 years ago. Marx said in Capital, Vol. III, Part III:

    “It (Capitalism) begins with primitive accumulation (Buch I, Kap. XXIV [English edition: Part VIII. — Ed.]), appears as a permanent process in the accumulation and concentration of capital, and expresses itself finally as centralisation of existing capitals in a few hands and a deprivation of many of their capital (to which expropriation is now changed).”

    Maybe the Professor just read this and got intoxicated with it but refused to complete the wise saying of Marx who then concluded by saying:

    “This process would soon bring about the collapse of capitalist production if it were not for counteracting tendencies, which have a continuous decentralising effect alongside the centripetal one”.

    This is not going to solve any of their self-induced problems. Every student of Marxism knows that:

    “Accumulation, in turn, hastens the fall of the rate of profit, inasmuch as it implies concentration of labour on a large scale, and thus a higher composition of capital. On the other hand, a fall in the rate of profit again hastens the concentration of capital and its centralisation through expropriation of minor capitalists, the few direct producers who still have anything left to be expropriated. This accelerates accumulation with regard to mass, although the rate of accumulation falls with the rate of profit.”

    Therefore, Capitalism itself is the big ‘expropriating’ force, suppressing private property of the means of production for many, in favour of private property for few. Over 50,000 jobs were lost in the deal and many former small capitalists re-dusted their Curriculum Vitae looking for non-existing jobs again.

    The forced bank mergers have led to over 5,000 jobs lost and over N170 billion depositors’ funds stock. The majority of these depositors are low and middle-income earners.

    Any direction capitalism goes, there is a catastrophe of unimaginable magnitudes for the Nigerian working class. There have been strikes of Nigerian Police twice within the lifetime of this regime; this is the consequence of these economic reforms. The crisis induced by these profit-seeking cannibals will continue as long as Capitalism is allowed to stay. Just as Chavez (Venezuelan President) said, Socialism or Death.

    With the interest rate standing at 36%, the inflation rate of 15% (and these are highly manipulated figures), millions either fully unemployed or not gainfully employed, life expectancy standing at 45 years, per capita GDP at $200 and incredible sums of debt hanging around, there is no way out on the path of Capitalism. Socialism remains the only way out for Nigeria.

    On The Web 
     cast your net a little wider...
     Radical Philosophy 
     African Studies Association (USA)  
     New Dawn Engineering 
     Indymedia Radio 
     Southern Africa Report online 
     Online Anti Apartheid Periodicals, 1960 - 1994 
     Autonomy & Solidarity 
     New Formulation 
     We Write 
     International Journal of Socialist Renewal 
     Journal of African Philosophy 
     British Library for Development Studies 
     The Nordic Africa Institute Online Library 
     Political Economy Research Institute Bulletin (PERI) 
     Feminist Africa 
     Jacques Depelchin's Tribute to Harold Wolpe 
     African Studies Quarterly 
     The Industrial Workers of the World 
     Anarchist Archives 
     Wholewheat Radio 
     Transformation: Critical Perspectives on Southern Africa  
     Zanon Workers 
     Public Citizen  
     Open Directory Project 
     Big noise films 
     London Review of Books  
     New York Review of Books 
     Monthly Review 
     New Left Review 
     Bureau of Public Secrets  
     Zed Books 
     Pluto Press 
     Duke University Press  
     Abe Books 
     The Electric Book Company 
     Project Guttenberg 
     Newspeak Dictionary 
     Feral Script Kiddies 
     Go Open Source 
     Source Forge 
     Ubuntu Linux Home Page 
     Software for Apple Computers 

    |  Contact Information  |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy