CCS Events
CCS Libraries
About CCS
CCS Projects
CCS Highlights

Publication Details

Bond, Patrick (2013) BRICS lessons in unsustainable urbanisation
Eye on Civil Society : -.

Some very dubious public policy lessons are being passed along within the Brazil-Russia-India-China-SA nexus. Durban’s Luthuli International Convention Centre will ring with even more bad advice this week during the BRICS ministerial conference entitled “Towards Sustainable Urbanisation.”

If there were justice in this city, aside from a lesson in Public Relations and a first-word title-change (to “Against”), the ICC would have on hand a tireless priest doing city-manager confessionals about the delegates’ socio-ecological record.

Tragically, on everyone’s mind is the terrible Chinese disaster last Friday morning. What spin-doctoring should BRICS delegates believe regarding Sinopec Corporation’s oil pipeline leak in Durban’s sister city of Qingdao, followed by a massive explosion?

With an estimated 60 dead, 130 injured and 18 000 evacuated, China’s State Administration of Work Safety quickly announced the culprits: “poor designs of the pipeline and local drainage networks, negligence on the part of safety officials, bad maintenance of the oil pipeline, as well as officials' failure to seal off the affected area and evacuate residents after they detected the leak, seven hours before the explosions.”

Sinopec responded by blaming Qingdao municipal officials – which here in Durban would be a plausible line of argument, given the decades-long failure of our city to come up with an emergency evacuation plan notwithstanding repeated pipeline leaks and refinery explosions in South Durban.

KwaZulu-Natal’s provincial politician responsible for city government, Nomusa Dube-Ncube, sent condolences on Monday, acknowledging that “Qingdao's delegation is set to make a presentation on building productive and sustainable urban economies at the Urbanisation Forum.”

That presentation could be ironic – though serious lessons are certainly badly needed in a city, Durban, strewn with white-elephant projects, including the ICC itself.

Indeed just before the Qingdao delegation landed in Durban, its airplane flew not far above a crumpled shopping mall under “construction”, visible from the air in Tongaat near the mainly empty King Shaka “international” airport.

That building remains a model of an unsustainable economic strategy: a new “aerotropolis” wannabe hub, just a 45 minute flight from Africa’s biggest airport. The R7 billion spent on it could have been put to use in bottom-up development – were it not for the unsustainable 2010 World Cup that catalysed its too-early construction, as well as the empty albeit world-class Mabhida Stadium next door to our world-class rugby stadium.

Popular hatred for all this centres on Jay Singh, the tenderpreneur-builder who wrecked so much of the nearby Phoenix community’s low-cost (and upon rebuilding, high-cost) housing, not to mention the city’s public bus service, and on former city manager Mike Sutcliffe, who egged on Singh and similar cronies, all those years, with hundreds of millions of taxpayer rands.

So this conference is terribly bad timing, at both ends of the sister-city relationship. “As we extend our condolences to our partners from Qingdao, we also hope to exchange with them our own insights from the rescue operation in Tongaat,” said Dube-Ncube.

Rescue? What about sharing insights about the causes, in Durban’s systematic corruption, with much more information about Singh drawn from the vast Manase Report that Dube-Ncube had herself commissioned and then tried to keep secret?

Or perhaps the Chinese team can share Sinopec insights into expanding oil transport through dense-packed residential sites? Sinopec seems to have no qualms about pollution, in a context, in many Chinese cities, where it is unsafe to breathe outside air conditioned buildings.

Yet Sinopec is so awful that in late August, the Chinese government suspended the huge firm from engaging in any new refining and chemical projects because it didn’t meet the government’s 2012 emissions targets.

The same crime – ignoring air quality legislation – is daily committed by our own leading energy corporation, Eskom, as well as by the South Durban oil refineries. Yet all continue moving forward with multi-billion rand expansions, including the doubling of the Durban-Joburg oil pipeline which was rerouted from white through black residential areas due, it would appear, to Transnet planners’ racism.

So if Sinopec is having trouble expanding at home, no doubt filthy South Africa offers a welcoming business environment in which to invest. In March, during the BRICS summit, Sinopec announced its partnership in the R80 billion Mthombo project at Port Elizabeth’s Coega zone, which will by 2015 allegedly build Africa’s single largest refinery.

These firms, urban officials and local government ministers will be pleased at the outcome of the Warsaw Conference of the Parties 19 to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change last weekend: “let the climate burn!”

Durban’s emissions remain higher than even London’s and Beijing, at 8 tonnes per person, with heavy industry and transport to blame. The failure of Singh’s bus service has a bit to do with that, but the main problem is the economic development strategy of our city and of the National Development Plan, based as it is on sports tourism, on petrochemical expansion, and on raising the port’s container traffic from 2.5 million to 20 million per year (please, not all routed over Field’s Hill, guys).

Just prior to SA hosting the COP17, the R250 billion plan for South Durban was conjured secretly by Transnet and Sutcliffe, with public information flowing like water-drip torture. In 2012, it suddenly became the country’s second largest Strategic Infrastructure Project (after coal exports through Richards Bay).

But resistance may turn the tide. Last month, for example, Transnet’s Environmental Impact Assessment for a huge berth expansion in the existing harbor was rejected by national government. By way of disclosure, on several occasions I questioned the draft EIA’s climate-change denialism, alongside the South Durban Community Environmental Alliance (SDCEA) which firmly opposes the port-petrochem mega-project for health, social, ecological and economic reasons.

SDCEA’s new 6-minute YouTube video, to be launched later today ( threatens Transnet with a financial sanctions campaign if their and allied oil companies’ attack on local communities persists.

  • In Wentworth, for example, Treasure Beach is under attack from Shell and BP (Sapref), as the Single Buoy Mooring pipeline that brings in 80 percent of SA’s oil is being moved to the traditional beach used by South Durban’s black residents.

  • And the Reunion farmers on land next to the old airport were just given notice they will be evicted, so Transnet can dig a fully-privatized new R100 billion port.

  • The area’s other green lung, the Clairwood Racecourse, is now being redesigned as a trucking logistics site in spite of unanimous opposition in neighbouring Merebank.

  • Clairwood itself remains under heavy pressure from trucking firms taking over and demolishing small houses and yards for the parking and repairs, leaving ten of their residents murdered under their wheels since 2005.

  • Transnet, meanwhile, dawdles on moving container freight from road-to-rail and setting up a dry port in Cato Crest, as the trucking mafia’s hostility to the idea grows.

  • A bit further southwards, Isipingo residents are now also opposed to the Transnet expansion.

  • They join concerned communities as far north and west as Queenstown, Pinetown, Sarnia, Umbilo and Glenwood fighting new trucking routes anticipated to create many more Field’s Hill-type massacres.

  • Durban’s other BRICS-twinned cities presenting at the ICC this week have also had their hands full with protesters: tens of thousands of non-violent democrats who swarmed St Petersburg in late 2011; in Mumbai, a constant cat-and-mouse struggle by slum-dwellers to survive the increasingly mean streets; and millions who hit the Rio de Janeiro streets in the middle of this year to fight public transport rate hikes and Sepp Blatter’s Zurich mafia.

    The worst lessons in crowd control, though, are homegrown: cops at Cato Manor police station who murdered an estimated 50 suspects since 2005, and top ruling-party figures who incited a community leader’s assassination at a Cato Crest mass meeting five months ago.

    BRICS from above will probably keep such lessons fresh this week. Perhaps in future years, a “brics-from-below” side event can teach the cities’ elites about genuine urban sustainability.

    Patrick Bond directs the UKZN Centre for Civil Society and edited the book, Durban’s Climate Gamble.

     cast your net a little wider...
     Radical Philosophy 
     African Studies Association (USA)  
     New Dawn Engineering 
     Indymedia Radio 
     Southern Africa Report online 
     Online Anti Apartheid Periodicals, 1960 - 1994 
     Autonomy & Solidarity 
     New Formulation 
     We Write 
     International Journal of Socialist Renewal 
     Journal of African Philosophy 
     British Library for Development Studies 
     The Nordic Africa Institute Online Library 
     Political Economy Research Institute Bulletin (PERI) 
     Feminist Africa 
     Jacques Depelchin's Tribute to Harold Wolpe 
     African Studies Quarterly 
     The Industrial Workers of the World 
     Anarchist Archives 
     Wholewheat Radio 
     Transformation: Critical Perspectives on Southern Africa  
     Zanon Workers 
     Public Citizen  
     Open Directory Project 
     Big noise films 
     London Review of Books  
     New York Review of Books 
     Monthly Review 
     New Left Review 
     Bureau of Public Secrets  
     Zed Books 
     Pluto Press 
     Duke University Press  
     Abe Books 
     The Electric Book Company 
     Project Guttenberg 
     Newspeak Dictionary 
     Feral Script Kiddies 
     Go Open Source 
     Source Forge 
     Ubuntu Linux Home Page 
     Software for Apple Computers 

    |  Contact Information  |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy